Pinch of Salt
AgingYouth said:
Muse = hyperkinetic Radiohead
Smashing Pumpkins = Cheap Trick meets The Cure
Nirvana = Just about every punk band...
Strokes = a Millennium update of Television (though I think they do it better than Television...)
Arcade Fire = a campfire version of Belle & Sebastian (sorry, just cannot get into them...)
There are definitely links... These days I'm more concerned about the quality of the songs than where the influences come from. But that's me. A memorable tune > nitpicking where I've heard the riff/ melody before...
Hear! Hear! It's about the quality of the tune and how it's presented. There is no such thing as a completely original band - and it's really quite pointless to base your judgement of a band based on how 'new' or different they sound. Because if you find a band unique, it's probably not because they are but more likely because you've never heard of or come across their influences. Come on, even champion bands like the Beatles, RHCP weren't really doing anything new. Paris Hilton on the other hand is a true pioneer.
But I'll still stick to my guns about 'tribute bands' pretending to be original bands. Definitely not for me.
As for the whole drugs thing, let me put in clearer terms for the benefit of those who perhaps might have read it wrongly. To read this as: when someone takes drugs, he will write a wicked tune, would be a flawed and literal reading of what I wrote. The drugs
culture is more than just about taking drugs. It's about a whole spectrum of experiences and emotions, both good and bad, that can be tapped into to produce a good and meaningful piece of music, that non drugs-takers might not understand. And the subtext, [or 'subutex'
], of the whole point, in summary, is that an omnipresent government breeds compliance and hinders creative expression. That's my interpretation of MacLaren's remarks, ,at least.
ps: It might be interesting to note that this remark, and others, were edited (read: censored) out of all press coverage of the MacLaren visit. I only got to know about it from a friend who was there at the press conference. Omnipresent, i tell you.
As for the German thing, my apologies. This is perhaps something that most of us might not understand - the blame-Germany-for-everything joke. It's like Irish, blonde, Jew, Malay, Indian, etc jokes. Point is: to be taken with a pinch of salt.
I love Kreator.
[/b]