Style Comparisons... JAM TIME!!!

eadricng said:
http://s19.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=1ZESPLI29GMF80YTOT6E70TFWG


here's my take on it.

If you find the startin' part familiar, i stole it from timmons.

Hmmm... dude, I would say, 2 main issues with the playing that doesn't make me go YEAH!

1. Phrasing is too cramped

2. Vibrato is sorely lacking

I hear some good note choices, esp when you revert to C min (?) pentatonics on some places and when you used some nice chromatics, but the vibe is simply not there.

Those 2 areas will bring your playing thru a LONG way.
 
siva said:
here's my tryout .. just using some simple pentatonic stuff .

influences ah .. haha.. rojak lar . u hear and tell me :)

opinions on how to improve greatly appreciated !!!!

have a listen : :wink:

http://s36.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=1UP0SUFIQ0PWX2KX3Q2XAI97UU

Chorus on all the time? :) It would get boring after a while, esp for a full song.... perhaps, use it sparingly?

I hear some good vibes in the beginning, but nearing the middle to the end, you lost it.

Methinks you got a good idea of how to emphasis notes like raking and what not, however, you need more ideas! I strongly suggest you take some backings and solo over them till you are sore. :) Really... "practising improvisation".

And lay off that chorus, give it as natural a tone as possible, not too much gain, then go for it. Its a totally different vibe that way, makes you rely so much more on picking dynamics and vibrato to spice up the song.
 
hifi_killer said:
alright heres mine..

http://s28.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=26R8YPDMPMR1X280IAF09LTTF6

well i havent play alot of guitar ever since i went to army..

Dude! Nice to hear your playing. :)

I guess the army has really taken a toll on your playing, you do sound forced and yes, the breathing is well, the song's done in 1 breath! Do relax, lay back and play slow.

Of special note,
1:11 - 1:15 has a VERY nice chromatic bit.. its very sweet. :) In fact is a brilliant idea.

I hear some good vibrato in your bends nearing the end around 2:40, but not at the beginning. Nearing the end, you got kind of stumped i think, repeating a lot and basically sounding quite lost.

Methinks what you need is better control of your phrasing. That is tops for you... because you evidently know how to do some good vibrato, its only that you don't do it as often as you should. ;) Phrasing man! Leave some space and then play hard!
 
bam said:
http://s36.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=25VZP2JVPPP6F1EY07XQ712S0Z

a 2nd take, cause i can't sleep.. so i tried to finish the whole track, and also try to keep to the same feel as my 1st attempt.. wheeee kinda got lost though..

Good take there! I hear good ideas and some excellent phrasing there!

The little break in the 2nd verse with the clean guitars was a neat idea, but i think (personally) the reverb was a bit too much, when your lead came in again, it got clouded out. Then again, its the mix not the playing.

The (pick?) tapping at 1:28 on sounded quite... forced and yeah, the sweet vibe you had was kind of lost till you got back to "conventional" soloing again. Little boo boo @ 1:44. ;)

The violining part thereafter also seemed to lack conviction. 2:03 onwards, when you started the repeated motif with violining, it somehow doesn't climax as it should (you were trying to bring it up aye?) but your normal tone did it.

2:33 onwards, I think you got sick of the improvisation! :D 2:43, you lost control of your normally wide and very nice vibrato.

2:48, the 2nd guitar came in at a bad time methinks... should have given it more space... but thats my opinion.

2:55, the run is well placed... pity it ended too early!

The weird noises thereafter, made the piece.. well... erm. Brought it down to earth. :)

I would think good placement of bends and vibrato in the beginning (the previous take was more "feel" to me) but the feel was thrown off and around for the remainder of the piece after the 2nd chorus.... I just think you need more experience. Nothing more. Cheers!
 
I got a lot to learn about mixing still, and i think i should get a better soundcard before i can get a slightly professional sounding recording.. As for tapping, its something im trying to work on.. I was tapping with pick :D Experimenting around lah :p
 
strats said:
http://s25.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=29DHYBIJ3M0HZ063LZQ1ZSRKAZ

my friend's jake's 2nd take. as i have mentioned before, he's a total noob at lead. if you find the intro familiar, its warm regards by vai.
hey, i think he improved a bit from the first one in the sense that he was playing thru the whole song. :) Its mostly off key i think, and from second half onwards, he seems to have run out of ideas/felt bored, and sounded like he was just fiddling around(not really playing like normal), hehe...but im no pro either, this is as far as i can say. :)

btw...wonder how to record like tt sia...i still using computer mic to record anything that i wanna record. :oops:
 
My friend sent me a instrumental piece... It sounded alot like your backing.. I mean it totally reminds me of your backing....

It's by artist - Shimokawa Mikuni
 
Back
Top