cbr400rrr,
My beef with your kind of reasoning is, unless you have clearly stated that highest offer seals the deal, then it's very misleading to the buyer whom you have agreed to reserve the item for. Bottom line is, a deal has been agreed on based on a specific price quoted, to be purchased on a specific date. My opinion is that the seller should honor that (unless it's a "best offer secures" type of sale). It's a very simple, gentleman's agreement. If a seller wants the best offer then state so up front, or put it up for auction, plain and simple.
Yes, at the end of the day it's the seller's prerogative whether to honor an agreement. However, maturity and professionalism clearly shows when the aforementioned type of dealing occurs.
To summarize, if you agree to deal on a set price on a set date, honor that deal. If you're a buyer who has reserved an item and the seller has agreed to put it aside for you, YOU BETTER KEEP YOUR WORD and purchase the said item at the agreed price. If you cannot keep to your end of the deal, IT IS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY TO INFORM THE SELLER ASAP.
To Sellers: to avoid headaches, be very clear and specific on your terms:
- If best offer seals the deal then say so
- If you don't want to entertain reservations then state this clearly