OK. A response finally from a reader and posted in ST today. Good reply. Not to say we should disregard the previous article. But here it is:
"GUYS, let's not panic.
According to recent news reports on emo kids, counsellors may have the impression that anyone listening to My Chemical Romance, wears a long fringe and eyeliner is likely to slash himself.
Five youth counsellors recently told The Straits Times that they are worried the emo fad, carried to extremes, can lead to self-mutilation or suicide among teens.
But this link is tenuous, at best.
To say an emo music fan is prone to self-harm is as unreasonable as saying that listening to the Sex Pistols' 1976 song Anarchy In The UK makes you a terrorist.
After all, emo music is just a new label for age-old angst - specifically, that of youth.
Music expressing sentiments such as alienation, loss and rejection has always lent a voice to tortured youth.
Similarly tortured kids in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s embraced the punk, goth and grunge music back then, even mimicked their idols, though I doubt many of them still walk around dressed like Robert Smith or Kurt Cobain.
There is nothing wrong with loving angsty music. Adolescence is a difficult time, and if identifying with music helps one cope with growing pains, then why not?
Besides, if the correlation is true, then emo, which has been popular for several years now, might have left far more dire consequences in its wake.
Bands such as Sunny Day Real Estate, Mineral and The Juliana Theory were all the talk about five years ago, while hot emo acts such as My Chemical Romance and Fall Out Boy have been the vogue in the last two years.
If they are blamed for causing teens to harm themselves only now, we need to consider if that is a fair accusation.
In the first place, emo music doesn't necessarily encourage self-mutilation.
Common themes among emo bands, such as Dashboard Confessional and Further Saves Forever, include heartbreak, the loss of loved ones, and being misunderstood - the stuff of any rock or pop fare on the radio.
Sure, the music's focus on one's emotional life allows an angsty listener to wallow in misery.
But whether this causes them to express their internal pain through self-harm has not yet been proven by any kind of scientific research.
So, maybe it is not time to freak out yet.
Blaming emo music only targets the means of self-expression, not the cause.
Perhaps it would better serve us to understand why some teens want to hurt themselves in the first place, before tackling the ways they do so."