Can anyone differentiate a Danelectro Transparent Overdrive with a Paul C's Timmy in a gig setting??
dodgethis said:
I would refine the question by adding on who can hear the difference, you or the audience, and whom it matters most to.
very important questions indeed. here, we discover that boutiques are not meant for everybody (else they won't be boutiques anyway right? >.<)
at the two extremes, there are people who's very practical and people who feel like going all out to achieve perfection. both have different expectations and both seek out to satisfy themselves
practical people will ask themselves the 1st question, answer it, and stop there.
"i am a performer, i showcase my craft to people at live venues. i can get a tone i want by only using a mass produced $100 pedal as compared to a boutique $300 pedal. on a live venue setting, slight differences in tone matters not because the audience will not be able to differentiate. thus i will go for the more practical option"
perfectionist and romantics will ask themselves the 2nd question.
"i am a performer, i showcase my craft to people at live venues. though i can get a tone near what i want by using a mass produced $100 pedal, it is not comparable to this boutique $300 pedal. whether on a live venue setting, or a studio recording session, i must use this particular pedal because it is the exact tone i am looking for."
this is just comparison of two extreme factors, excluding everything else such as wealth, market awareness and stuff. most of us are people in between and thus, we usually end up with some compromises.
for me, personally, i can be an unreasonable control freak at times. i need to get the exact tone i want, where ever i go. due to budget reasons, i cannot yet try the hundreds of boutiques out there, though i would like to. being the practical person i am, i have to find the best way to work within these limitations. i settle for the next best thing within tight budget, pod x3 live. i gotta admit it doesn't exactly respond (i can't say the same for sound, because sometimes i can't tell) like the real thing, but with enough tweaking, i will be happy with what i get. i can spend over an hour tweaking one tone on it just to get what i want. this is how i still get to be a control freak within my own limitations.. =D
put some money in my bank and i'm pretty sure boutique stuff will start appearing in my home studio! nobody escapes from gas! haha :twisted: