singaore idol SHOWDOWN ... SLY VS TAU

whos the better singer ? taufik / slyverster ur vote counts

  • slyvester

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • taufik

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
i agree..he's better than Sly in every ways..that y 68% of votes go to Taufik..
he can do rnb, hip hop, jazz..and if u r into rock..u definitely know dat Taufik can do rock as well judging by his voice...he's an all rounder..if only i can get taufik in my rock band......
if u have a rock band..would u take Sly as ur vox? :lol: some might but not me..
 
Revolutions said:
i wouldn't. i want someone who has at least speaks english well, and has charisma.

lol

+1 ....

might give band bad image by rounding up a gig with

" no matter what happens , [to fans] i will always love you" , then give the irritating dunno wad salute or sumthing.

btw ... i think hes quite misguided ... he wan do rock as part of his recording contract but the record companies going to shape him to something mandopop or sum thing that will become closer to pop than rock ...

kidna sad rite ? his "dream" turned out into distorted nightmare

:twisted: like we care :D
 
Re: Sly my ass.

seekz said:
I'm not really for the IDOLS shit.
.
.
.
.
I voted Taufik 27 times for this....

wow that quite interesting. You must have hated slyvester so much that u voted against him 27 times.Ever wondered whos gonna pay for the phone bill?
 
Frankly, Douglas O would be laughing his a*s off this "self-proclaimed rock star" who admire Axl Rose n wants to be like him (in ST Life section), but end of the day, cannot even "tarek" the rock tone properly. Sounds more like a toad croaking when he tries to roughen his voice. This young punk should go hear how Douglas sing, and feel ashamed for the rest of his life. But then again, he's probably too young to catch Mr. Oliveiro in his glorious days.

More of an average, not too bad singer, the biggest problem with Sim is probably his lost of identity instead. If one proclaims to be a rocker, he does not also try to sound like boybands or trying to make a name for himself as Singapore's Jay Chou. Jay's a hardcore R&B, n his music is far away from rock. These 2 just don't blend together. Well, like most ppl, he can try to slyly "roti-prata" his statement later by proclaiming versatility. But sadly, that just threw him into the same category of "everybody else" then.

A rocker is someone who swears to his roots, even when all the young girls in the world hate rock N'Roll (we're near!). A true- blue rocker's 1st priority is never abt selling-out, but to share this raw sugar that lives in his blood, and even when its means a drop in sales figure. End of the day, he's just another sucker (oops, do i mean singer?) who would do anything for fame.

In the near future, he would see his dreams come true as chinese record companies come flooding their offers for a contract. But as time goes by, he'll just be another identityless, easily-forgotten average singer.
 
Dun flame me people, i vote her for slyvester cos i like to hear him scream only. though i feel that taufik is a better singer and deserve to win, i somehow like slyvester more....but dun like the way he show off about being a rocker and so on.
 
seekz, you said you are not really for the IDOL but you voted 27 times? 8O

ficiante, would you take britney spears as your vocal? I will. :lol:

Revolutions, he doesnt need to have good English, he's a singer!

stars, he's already got the deal with the recording company. how cool is that!

ok, enough of bashing. we should support everyone who is doing music.
 
i vote for sim because i like to see more of him. he's like mr bean. very funny.

if he's in world idol, lagi funny!

lol! whoaaahaaahaa...........
 
i read on the paper that sly's parents are bankrupt or sumthing....
the media is really heartless to have disclosed such information about him... he is afterall only starting out.

lost singapore idol...mum goes to jail... both incidents exposed to the whole of singapore..



i still prefer sly. taufiq got the fake look .. when he win..the

" i just got the air knocked outta me look " ... then must straight away hug the nearest person.... abit lame la...every episode do the same thing.
 
soft said:
stars, he's already got the deal with the recording company. how cool is that!

ok, enough of bashing. we should support everyone who is doing music.

ja ja he got contract


but the saddest thing is that he get contract but cant even sing what he originally set out to do . rock . its kinda sad how the industry will manipulate to become a commercial successs...

but how much of a success can he be if true blue rockers here at soft dun supoort him too :P ?

just being cynical about sly :D
 
there are many choices in life, some you will be glad that you'd made them and some you kinda regret. many of your choices will also be affected by external means. like if i want to buy a guitar but i do not have enough money to get the expensive one, what do i do? well, life goes on.

for the Idols, they made the choice to take part in the competition, they work hard to come so far and it will be their choice to continue the path they set.

for myself, i work in the creative industry, or so i thought. my ideas are my pride. but do you know how often my pride is shot down by my client? what do i do? i just have to re-organise and present to the client again.

for the Idols, this is only their first step into the commercial world. they will mature, evolve and grow into what they will be, eventually.
 
no choice

no choice? hv to pay the bills mah?

pay your bills first then worry about creativity and artistry!
no money no talk. when you make it, whatever come out
of you mouth, all will say GOOD ?! All are just people !!??
 
soft said:
for the Idols, this is only their first step into the commercial world. they will mature, evolve and grow into what they will be, eventually.

ic wad u mean

if life give u lemons make lemonade ?

yea ... but the last part ... how much control do they have over to do with thier music they produce ... its very very sad ...

BMG probably paid top dollar to cash in on all the idols ( it holds exclusive right to sign on and rake big bucks out of each idol ) . companiies bottomline come first , the people are secondary.

like ac / dc song , its a long way to the top :

" Gettin' ripped off
Under-paid
Gettin' sold
Second hand
That's how it goes "
 
how much control? well, for starters, why ask for control? maybe when we are really up there. you know what i mean? :wink:

if BMG would come to me and say, "James, I want you to sing hokkien songs". I will say, "Sure, why not?" As a professional, we have to act professionally. Did you see the band that was playing during the finals? All are top-notch professional musicians. Do they say, "I dont like this kind of music" or "I play only rock"?

Same thing for the Idols, once they are on stage, they are professionals. Meaning they have a job to do and they better do it well.
 
are you not entertained ?

soft said:
how much control? well, for starters, why ask for control? maybe when we are really up there. you know what i mean? :wink:

ic wad u mean

as entertainers , regardless of what form of music we sing /play / do we must seize it when the opportunity comes to do it ? its performance that we seek ?

dunno . to me the work defines the artist . its like saying you are what you eat. but that is idealism . anything else means a sell out of your ideals

real world practicaliscism demands that we mould ourselves to fill whatever gap that the public wants . to fulfill the desires of a market.

ic wad u mean james ! music for career and music for passion is 2 diff things
 
soft said:
Do they say, "I dont like this kind of music" or "I play only rock"?

Same thing for the Idols, once they are on stage, they are professionals. Meaning they have a job to do and they better do it well.

i get what you mean. i beg to differ about sly, he tries to change every song he sings into a rock tune, even though it doesn't fit the song. but his fans are still tone-deaf to this, they think every song he sings is nice just because he winks at them. i feel like burning my tv set. =(
 
hmmm... so is it the fans that you are not comfortable with or the singer? dont take it out on the TV. Just dont watch it. :lol:
 
Back
Top