"You don't need perfect pitch to tell its out of tune. Btw, killinghall stated it out of tune too, you could pick a bone with him too."
Yes, I said the Bach rendition is out of tune, and it certainly is. Guitar wasn't tuned properly, and the pitch intonation resulting from poorly pressed strings didn't make it sound good.
That said - it was a very good attempt considering the mental effort put into remembering all those notes.
And since it's just an informal take - not a concert video or competition - let's really take this with a pinch of salt, and just appreciate what was shown to us.
The other piece, however, was more pleasing to the ears as far tuning is concerned.