How many of you changed your playing when you pick up different guitars?

Whitestrat

New member
I began playing Ibanez guitars from day one. Was always a fan of the Satriani/Vai style of playing. Then, a quick switch even to Les Pauls was possible, when Slash came along. Humbuckers were seemingly easy to play and articulate. It was easier to get a nice tone from a HB than a single coil, and I sort of always ignored single coils. For some reason, i steered away from Strats. Never knew what to do with them, and always thought they sounded weak and puny; sometimes bordering on the wimpy side of tones.. My idols then were people like Satch, Slash, Petrucci, Gary Moore... Mostly HB players. My playing techniques were very much focused on making the guitar sound as cohesive as possible, whether plicking one note, or playing chords. Everything needed to be tight and compact. After a while, I realised my playing was rather stiff, and though fluid, it wasn't really alive. Just going through the notes. I sort of fell into a tur for a while, and retired my guitars for a couple of years, only touching them on rare occasions.

Then, almost 16 years later after SRV's death (2 years from that retirement point), I sort of picked up a strat just for the fun of it. Simply because I was in Japan, looking for something to buy, and since I was there, and had CHOICE of Japan Strats, I grabbed a 68. To be honest, I tried playing the thing, and I realised that I'm still playing like I used to on all those guitars, and somehow didn't find the experience exciting or satisfying.

Yet something was different. This guitar sort of challenged me. I couldn't play it as easily as I did my other guitars, and had to fight with it tooth and nail to get a decent tone. I had no clue what it was that was different, just that I sounded BAD on a strat. My pure chance, I started getting heavily into the blues, and went on a vintage music kick. Stones, Clapton, SRV, Hendrix, Deep Purple, Knopfler etc etc. I suddently realised that while I had been playing for quite sometime before this, I couldn't really play what I was hearing on those records. Especially what I heard on SRV's stuff. I went on to try learning some SRV songs, and realised, my picking technique, fretting technique and even strumming techniques needed to change.

The sad thing is, the strat made me realise how limited a player I was, and how narrow-minded I used to be. I realised that I could not play a strat decently, no matter how technically proficient I thought I was.

Once I managed to identify what those things were and how to do them, I began realising what I tone machine a strat could be with JUST the neck single coil. I began to hone my skills even further using a single coil and shaping my attack and phrasing. My legatos took on slightly different forms, and I realised that I just had to play a strat different from anything else with a humbucker. I learnt to rake, scrape, chug and slide like I never had to do before.

This led to a flurry of sessions strictly with a strat in the last 2 years, forcing myself to play cleaner than before, and since a strat is so unforgiving, I had to pay closer attention to what I played. When you have less gain to hide behind, you have to make your notes count. I had to begin crafting my improvised melodies even more carefully than I did when I was playing with humbuckers.

Then I eventually got into Lynyrd Skynyrd and ZZ Top. Boy, that really screwed my head. The way they made those humbuckers snap and bite like single coils was mind boggling. Again I had to relook at my playing style, and I realised I had to change again what I was playing on an LP. I was now (ironically, thanks to the strats) able to play cleaner and differently on any guitar. The strats changed the way I played for the better, and forced me to be less reliant on gear, and more reliant on my hands and ears.

Now, I'm thankfully able to play all sorts of things. From Gary Moore to SRV to Satriani to Petrucci to Nightwish to Muse. It's sort of moulded my playing style into something that my friends have said it sort of defines me. All because I went to try to learn something different because of an irritating design with single coils. That sort of got me out of a rut that I was stuck in for more than 10 years. I now see the value in all sorts of guitar types, from Gretschs to Jaguars to Teles to ES335s etc etc. And the best part is that I'm now able to sound decent on all of them. (I think)

Anyone else have this sort of epiphany in their playing because of a different type of gear?
 
I played a strat when I started out cos it was a gift and got me started on guitar. Played punk in my early years so didn't really require much off a guitar cept to play a few power chords.

2 years ago I started going deeply into Jrock and wouldn't you know it I got myself a mocking bird with a FR. Betcha can guess who my fav band was huh?

Now that I've long moved past my Jrock phase I'm started to feel the constraints of the mocking bird. Examples? It slides down on one side, I can't do much cept legato on the higher frets cos of the horn blah blah blah. Now that I'm really into prog stuff, I find myself yearning for more simplistic guitar that won't stand in my way. I'm a leftie so buying guitars is a BIG issue for me.

Back to the point. I recently picked up a leftie strat the other day to try out some pedals. I feel that whenever I pick up a strat now, I'm inclined to play a little 'little wing'.

I guess my point would be that, different players with different guitars resonate and leave an impression within us. Picking up a different guitar may trigger some of those feelings and thus we change to a different playing style altogether.

Or maybe subconsciously we know that different guitars ARE for different genres and thus we change our playing style when we pick up one. And ya I hope to have a vast collection of DIFFERENT guitar models so I can go 'I feel like alil blues today' and pick up a strat.

Anyway my 2cents.
 
I play differently too.

I kind of liken multiple guitars to playing with different picks though.

After a while, it doesn't matter as much - you'll be okay/good/proficient at all of them. You'll still play them your way, maybe different shades, but yeah, still you on guitar.
 
playing differently on different guitars, but sound come out, in general still geetar sound and what we can play on the guitar, will still make it sound like ourself.

lets move on.

How can we move beyond guitar and still make music that sound like ourself?
 
Hmm.

I had a similar experience moving from dual humbuckers to a dual single-coiled telecatser. It took some time to get used to the string height from the body, the single-coil tone and yes... that guitar made me refine my technique in order to get a good sound out of it. And I'm a better player now =)
 
Very cool story~ Hope the kids read it to gain some invaluable points from more experience softies.

When I fell into country and Tele players in general (Jazzers play Teles ya' know) and got a Tele, instantly I started to mould into a Tele centric picker. Started getting used to the further away volume knob, got better at changing pickups without muting your guitar accidentally, started finding where I could fret and bend the notes behind the nut, started fretting in ways to enhance the harmonic nature of the Tele, chicken pickin'... All fine and good.

Then I picked up a friend's Strat. My gosh the middle pickup is IN THE WAY. I couldn't control the volume knob as well as I used to on my Valley Arts. The neck pickup sounds pretty darn different. It felt thinner to the body. These made me uncomfortable playing it. I didn't sound good at all. I mean, Stratocaster has a killer design practically molded for a guitar player, with many electronic options and ergonomics, and here I am muddling everything. Took me a good while to be able to handle Strats better.

The other day I picked up a Tokai SG. Angus was my absolute inspiration when I started playing, so I thought them meaty powerchords and pentatonic wailing will be coming up, look out Bukit Timah Plaza!

THEN my friends started shaking their heads when what came out at first was some Brad Paisley nonsense. The neck was too thin. Somehow the bridge and humbuckers got in the way and I don't know why. Stupid middle finger always wanting to pick something. I don't know how to play above the 17th fret anymore. What am I doing with this? Why am I not playing open power chords? Why did I start playing some jazzy blues? Not cool on the SG dude.

I guess for my case, my guitar has changed me rather then I change to be better for individual guitars. Until my Valley Arts come back, I will be a Tele-headed cock banging his head on other guitars trying to sound decent.
 
yes, very interesting thread this. I definitely change my style of playing with different types of guitars used.
For instance, I almost always use finger picking whenever I play on a Tele, classical or acoustic. I almost always use plec and finger on a Gretsch and Gibson ES335. And for some reason, I tend to chug more on humbucker guitars like my fake-o SG than on my strat.
The songs change too. I think because I'm a bit of a traditionalist, I cannot think to play old rockabilly or rock and roll songs (up till 1958) and American R&B/blues songs circa '60s on anything but a 335.
For Brit rock/pop songs, I almost always tend to favour the strat; and of course, I like my Rickenbacker for anything Beatles (64 to 65), Byrds, REM, U2 (Mysterious Ways, Gone, Angel Of Harlem, Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own only) or Radiohead.
Funnily, I'm very lazy so I don't bring more than two guitars to gigs (and even then, it's only because I need to play acoustic and electric for the night). I'll bring just the one if possible (usu the strat or SG 'cos they're more versatile).
Sounds silly right?
 
I started out on strat because I was heavily influenced by the blues. SRV, Hendrix, Clapton etc. And I always felt that HB guitars were too muddy for my liking. So throughout my 5 years of playing, it always have been strats strats strats and playing all kinds of music on it. Guess what whitestrat is true, I'm definitely narrow-minded

Up until recently, when I didn't have my strat back in time for a jam session, I had to settle for a Les Paul which one of my friends had so kindly lent it to me. Initially, I really struggled to get the sound right, the neck feels different, its a totally different sound. But somehow, after changing the way I play(picking intensity/strumming etc), I noticed that the LP was a great guitar with a real edge to the sound.

So I guess, it would always be good to adapt the way you play to the guitar. But somehow, certain techniques and influence would still be apparent. Like my picking is more precise and I can control the intensity at which I attack the strings etc. Perhaps this is due to what Whitestrat said, a strat is more unforgiving. So I guess I'm lucky to have started out on a strat and sort of hone my skills and have come to appreciate the beauty of the various guitars other than a strat...
 
Took me a good while to be able to handle Strats better.

You KNOW what I'm talking about!

Junior_ said:
Up until recently, when I didn't have my strat back in time for a jam session, I had to settle for a Les Paul which one of my friends had so kindly lent it to me. Initially, I really struggled to get the sound right, the neck feels different, its a totally different sound. But somehow, after changing the way I play(picking intensity/strumming etc), I noticed that the LP was a great guitar with a real edge to the sound.

Yep, same thing happened to me the first time I picked up a Les Paul after playing RG, Radius and S Series for so long. Struggled with the LP. But that wasn't as bad as the Strat. I didn't struggle to know how to play the LP. I struggled with the upper fret access and the odd distance from the body of the guitar to my picking hand. (can't anchor my pinky there no more!) but playing the guitar with technique was easy, since it was still primarily a HH guitar. Getting it to sound decent isn't difficult. The strat was a real 13iatch!
 
Last edited:
well for me, i started on a strat and i'm still playing strats till now, theres this lovely thing about a single coil, be it clean, slightly driven or over the top gained, it still retains that smoothness about it, there's that snappiness to it.

indeed the strat is a very unforgiving instrument, its just waiting for you to make that one mistake and then amplify it through your amp, shaming you in the process, but in that way, it helps you to be more cautious about your playing, to try to be cleaner.

i've owned and used many other guitars over the years, les pauls, teles, RG's, and various other guitars, but i've always went back to the strat, so much so that infact i've at one point owned 3 strats at a go.

i guess there's just something about the sexyness of a strat, it just leaves you begging for more, and even though you know at any mistake, the strat will come out and bite you right in the nose, you still wanna go back there, it's like some magic chakra or something.

and yes, the strat has helped me in my playing alot, but still nothing feels more like home, then a full maple, standard C shaped neck with 3 singlecoils and the sexy curves that define what a strat is.
 
Yeah, I kinda agree that the strat is unforgiving, but I guess the magic abt it is the sound, somehow there is this draw to the single coil sound. and how it helps one to develop our playing.
 
Different types of guitars.

Of course we can't play the same way with a Les Paul, A strat, superstrat, acoustic , classical guitar. If you do, that means chances are, you may not be tapping their individual potential properly.

I have been playing strats for the past 16 years and I find it a struggle to adapt to my les pauls every once in a while.

Don't get me wrong, I feel both are great types of guitars, but its just that the strat is to me, more versatile.The difference in the bridges already make you work hard to compensate where u rest ur muting hand.The pickup selector you will need to adapt too.

I realize that playing a superstrat like Ibanez or EBMM is so much easier but psychologically unappealing. No idea why, just me I guess. Its all about vintage appeal probably.

For me, there's this mojo when fighting for the perfect tone on a normal strat, its hard to describe really.If you're off on a strat, you're way off, but if you hit the right spots, the results are always inspiring.It has everything to do with the ridiculously dated design, the scale length, and of course making your pups sing the way it should thru lots of patience..I can dig in more, and be more percussive in my attacks.I cant seem to that with my friend's J craft Ibanez.
 
Snuff, curious - have you tried a superstrat that is equipped with lower output pickups?

Does it seem to capture a more strat vibe? In terms of the playability you mentioned

I donno if Andy Timmon's AT100 counts as a superstrat - but yes.

Really love how the way the cruisers break up when you hit 'em hard...altho my Areas on my strat still does the breakup thing better
 
Snuff, curious - have you tried a superstrat that is equipped with lower output pickups?

Does it seem to capture a more strat vibe? In terms of the playability you mentioned

hey no man, never did try, ok ok, im just biased la, my bad hurhurhur

seriously, the strat vibe is the whole feel la, the radius, the uncomfortable stretching, and the occasional mishit notes!
 
hey no man, never did try, ok ok, im just biased la, my bad hurhurhur

seriously, the strat vibe is the whole feel la, the radius, the uncomfortable stretching, and the occasional mishit notes!

No lah, i'm not saying you're bias-ed but I didn't have a lot of time on real strats - so I thought you might know.

I do know that when I went with my superstrat with really low output pickups, I struggled like crazy. Granted, flatter radius, bigger frets, etc etc - but the pups mattered a lot... I couldn't make the thing sing AT ALL when I first got it.
 
I salute you in advance if you can make your strat sound like my Jackson Warrior loaded with SD Blackouts just by 'playing differently'. Different playing field brother.
 
In my case I'm more affected by the type of pickup rather than the type of guitar. I'm one of those who feels equally comfortable with a Strat and a Les Paul. Generally, I'm more of a lead player with singlecoils and more of a rhythm player with humbuckers. I play mostly rhythm so I end up using my humbucker more than my two singlecoils though.

Slowly doing some interchanging. :mrgreen:
 
I salute you in advance if you can make your strat sound like my Jackson Warrior loaded with SD Blackouts just by 'playing differently'. Different playing field brother.

If you want power, nothing beats a Gibson Les Paul. IMO.

But a strat can come pretty close if it has two high-output humbuckers...
 
Back
Top