thor666
New member
Actually, different pedals sound different on different amps, even when eliminating technique and cables in the equation. I think cable tones are still relatively similar as long as you're not using particular cables which cut frequencies or have special applications.
And even then, loudness can play a part in whether a pedal sounds good through the same amp, perhaps very much so in tube amps, where the amp has a non-linear volume structure. It's interesting to read that some people hate say, the Bad Monkey for it's perceived muddiness, while others may claim the Bad Monkey as the holy grail when cranking up a particular amp.
I'm not sure if you agree, but my personal experience is that you tend to be able to "guess" whether a piece of equipment works for you by looking at that player's other equipment. So for example, when looking at a pedal on HarmonyCentral, I'll just take the reviews of people with a similar guitar and amp combination as better opinions, and try to spot for technical data which can explain why a certain pedal sounds good in a particular context.
Of course, if you can try something out, you should take your time to try the pedal out fully, preferably with your own personal set up.
And even then, loudness can play a part in whether a pedal sounds good through the same amp, perhaps very much so in tube amps, where the amp has a non-linear volume structure. It's interesting to read that some people hate say, the Bad Monkey for it's perceived muddiness, while others may claim the Bad Monkey as the holy grail when cranking up a particular amp.
I'm not sure if you agree, but my personal experience is that you tend to be able to "guess" whether a piece of equipment works for you by looking at that player's other equipment. So for example, when looking at a pedal on HarmonyCentral, I'll just take the reviews of people with a similar guitar and amp combination as better opinions, and try to spot for technical data which can explain why a certain pedal sounds good in a particular context.
Of course, if you can try something out, you should take your time to try the pedal out fully, preferably with your own personal set up.