Armchair Critic vs WORMROT (A Little More Competition)

[AEnimic]

Wormrot sounds nice. Good stuff. I mean, yeah, I don't usually enjoy Grindcore...but that's nice stuff.

 

[ROT]

thanks doood

 

[vx02]

no prizes for guessing the winning horse!

BEER OR NOTHING.

 

[dir]

pfft anybody can write a song, i suggest a youtube rock-out challenge for these two bands. then we can see which ones rock out!

 

[AEnimic]

thanks doood

No problem bro

 

[soft]

Yup, to win, they will have to go all way out. If they are thinking of doing the bare minimum, they will sure lose out to the other party.

* I was judging in a few band competitions and often, it is not how good the band is, it is just how bad the other bands are.

 

[lordie]

i vote for wormrot -

k, great, they win, thx bye.

 

[growlingsoulpup]

This sounds like an awful lot of fun. Are all the competitions gonna be based on the idea of writing songs on demand?

 

[marcdadrummer]

Woah sounds fun siol!

 

[singaporean]

healthy competition ftw

 

[Genocide BlackWolf]

o.o it this like a poll/vote based judge or just "the admins" gets to choose who win the competition?? just asking.. that's all.. cheers with beers!!! grind till you rot!!!

 

[Chaserr]

is this some kind of mashup? because, they are performing, in their own renditions, separately, in terms of genres.

 

[singaporean]

armchair critic was great when i saw them
never seen wormrot live before though ... paiseh
go for it y'all lol

 

[Tribalcast]

Rot, just give them one of your parody songs. That might just do the trick. Hahah.

 

[FrancescaAnn]

* I was judging in a few band competitions and often, it is not how good the band is, it is just how bad the other bands are.

Will this be applied to the AC vs WR battle? Because i have to admit both bands are equally good in their respective genres. I'm curious to know how a versus band battle would be carried out considering the different styles of music influence and techniques in both bands. What will judging be based on? I'm interested to know how James differentiates a good band from a bad one.

So excited, can't wait for this!!

 

[soft]

You realise I never state how they should present their song? Hee..hee.. If one simply write out some lyrics with chord chart and the other make a video with good production value, the audience will be able to choose which one they like better.

I am also very eager to see what both bands come out with. Hope it will set the standard for subsequent battles.

 

[pf]

This sounds like fun!

 

[empihsrow]

This is really engaging. And it's a good way to showcase the qualities of bands. Although it'll be hard to judge the final products at the end, everyone will win in the end.

 

[hecklerkoch]

This is really engaging. And it's a good way to showcase the qualities of bands. Although it'll be hard to judge the final products at the end, everyone will win in the end.

Somehow you sound like a politician.

Or at least a marketing guy.

:mrgreen:

 

[lars_ulrich]

1. They learn to create music under the pressure of time- Say if these two bands make it big some day, they may be under the pressure of the record company to come up with their next big hit single within a limited time frame.

UNDER PRESSURE TO WRITE A HIT SINGLE? REALLLLLY?HOW STUPID IS THAT? SO MUCH FOR MUSIC BEING AN ARTFORM!

=pinkfloydrose

6. We get to judge and perhaps discuss the pros and cons of the two songs that the bands would have created, which will serve as critique for the bands to further themselves musicwise.

LAME! THIS ISNT SOME GP ESSAY MY DEAR!


Mr Soft, what are you trying to achieve with this? Seriously, isn't music supposed to be personal? So why the need for judging and all this competition?