some comments:
the Gothic re-launch was in part Gibson's efforts to offset the dissent for the Menace series. however, the real intentions behind the re-launch remains debatable.
when i reviewed the Anniversary 2005 LTD F-model, i received limited responses pertaining to the EC version. it's good to see a renewed interest 8) however, keep in mind that Gibson was the initiator of the satin black colour scheme, LTD went one-up by incorporating the EMGs in their EC.
FYI- the current Gothic model isn't an accurate reproduction of the debut version, current differences being (the EMG pickups aside):
*absence of 12th fret crescent/ star marker
*current rosewood fretboard vs the initial ebony version
*'Les Paul' decal on current Gothic LP
the original Gothic
it's quite immaterial to pit the Gothic against the Epi version which is refered to as the Goth series (not
Gothic), in any case, further discussion on this basis is akin to splitting hairs.