i love sugizo !!
to me guitar is not just about notes and the music, but also the image and performing flair. if u want to sit down and play go do it in ur bedroom. and u have to say sugizo has a unique style all of his own, even if u may not like it.
music-wise he may not be a very technical guitarist, but anyone who thinks he can't shred should go listen to the solo at the end of 'crazy about you' on the lunacy album. his style of soloing is slow single notes with lots of emotion, very melodic, punctuated by sudden rapid bursts of speed. so dun diss him on his technical ability. he's also a violinist btw
image-wise, not everyone likes makeup, but u can't deny the effort jrock artistes put into their onstage appearance. no one wants to pay big bucks to watch a couple of shaggy t-shirt wearing slobs on stage, unless u r one too. sugizo may be a bit too flashy, which may not be to everyone's taste. still, lots of ppl love it, myself included (n i am a straight guy btw)
can't really compare hide to sugizo, just like u can't really compare x japan's music to luna sea. they r really very different. x is still heavily influenced by 80s western rock, whereas there's no trace of that in luna sea.
as for comparing sugizo to inoran, well ... what comparison is there? to those who've heard inoran's sucky solo works, u wonder where all the talent he undoubtedly had in the earlier days has gone.