Yeah, looking at the panel doesn't seemed to make wtaching SI an exciting option. They are not known for their quick wits or comments. In fact, except for Dick, Florence and Ken are so low profile that no one really knows them much. As for Douglas O, I feel he's a disappointing choice as he 's a pub rocker, not exactly a seasoned recording star. There are different standards when singing in pubs and doing studio recordings.
I can already see a very safe approach when all the judges will try to be very diplomatic and tactful so as not to hurt and make the contestant lose too much face.
I suppose the real entertainment now relies very much on the goofy and off-key singers. By the time we get to the good singers, it's another Talentime without the prizes.
8)