Hey Ar0Rose,
I can't give you much opinion about the
S-1 cos I have NO IDEA how it sounds like or works. All I know is how it looks like. LOL.
But there's always YouTube if you wanna check the sound out.
And reading reviews online, I noticed that majority of the buyers said that the guitar is not very versatile and the stock Duncan pickups can go from Amazing to Horrible in just a year.
Here's a few quotes copied from the review site.
"I play anything from pop-punk all the way up to death metal and I have to say that this guitar unfortunately does not cover them all. I run it through a Line 6 Spider II 30 Modeling amp with a little reverb and it sound spectecular at first. The Duncan's sound very rich and full at first but they start to wear out and get deep. They give out good distortion but not enough for soloing"
"I decided to change the Duncans to the almighty EMG 81/85 combination. Now it sounds like a Demon thanks to the wood quality of the S1. In conclusion about the sound. The S1 sounds beautiful at first but after at least a year of playing with it. You would want to pull out the Duncan pickups and put in somthing else."
On the other hand, a friend of mine gave a 2 thumbs up for "
The Lady Luck"
He's been using it for about 6 months already.
The guitar has this push/pull coil tap which in my opinion, the player needs some getting used to cos I was clueless and didn't find it useful when I first got to know about it.
When you figure out what it's for, it works great!
My friend plays cover bands ranging from Alesana, Killswitch Engage to Bullet for my Valentine and he said it works great, though it has the Schecter stock Alnico pickups.
He uses a Peavey classic amp, with some effect pedals which I can't quite get what he's saying. hahahahaha
Also, he likes it cos the neck is freaking smooth!
So, I shall pop by his place one day and try out the Lady Luck, and probably give you my thought about it.
Cos it sounded awesome from the way he described it.
And yes, Shawn Milke uses Lady Luck for recording of Alesana's 2nd album. So you can pretty much hear how it sounded like, especially on the track "Obsession is Such an Ugly Word" intro.
So there you have it.