M-audio 88 weighted keys VERSES! CME Weighted keys keyboard!

garagesale_01

New member
which one is better? in terms of specs and price...
yuo guys have e price?
and also.. can both of em work well with mac software like garageband and logic?
thanks!!
 
Extremely personal. Depends on preferences.

M-audio has more faders and knobs - which is nice especially for sequecing/mixing multiple tracks and playing live with VSTi plug-ins. But I have a gripe with it's touch. Do a search on the forum and you'll see reviews and opinions on this.

Although I haven't tried the CME, but they use GEM rp series keys which I believe are from Fatar which I've played on before. Yes, Fatar keys are not the best but definitely better than M-audio's. I recall CME having driver problems and I'm not sure if they have solved that problem. But you can use their midi out instead of USB to connect to PC - that way you don't have to worry about drivers.

Because the CME's body is aluminium, it is definitely heavier. M-audio is really very light and good for carrying about - but I feel that it may break easily and I don't feel too good about it's plywood bottom.

Both will work for garageband and logic - and all similar software. It's just a controller - controls are assignable and therefore flexible.

Before CME came out, M-audio got the upper-hand in cheap midi controllers. Looks like they now have a tough competitor. It will be interesting to see how this develops...

You can see I'm geared more towards CME. But it is unfair since I've not actually played on it. Although I have a rough idea on it's touch and responsiveness, I've not tried it's controls - how responsive are the faders, knobs, mod wheels and pitch bend. One thing for sure - they used their brains by putting the controls (faders etc) on the left-hand side. More ergonomic since we usually use our right hands to play and left hand to control. M-audio made this big blunder by putting it the other way round.
 
WOAH! a detailed reply!!
anyway you got any idea how much these two are??
currently i do my recording on my laptop, and my laptop has no midi in..
i have m-audio mobilepre.. does it work??
 
much has developed since its release earlier this year.

the USB driver has improved much, although i've never had problems with them myself, the earliest driver i've installed, v1.03 ran perfectly for me. there were problems in the beginning, but none that crippled basic usage of the board, mostly nitty gritty program-support details that any new product would experience when first out on the market. the tech guys participate actively on their forum, and new problems are being solved constantly and promptly, which i think is something that few other manufacturers actually offer. support for many programs has been improved much since. in fact, some of the forummers themselves help to contribute to development work.

check out the progress here at http://www.cme-pro.com/forum
anyone interested in this board must definitely look this up before buying. many ppl come to this forum. newbies, pros, hobbyists.

i can personally say(since i have one, and gigged with it) i have no gripes with the faders, knobs or any controller features. breath control unit worked flawlessly too. slider motion is smooth, however the knobs all have a center detent. can be both advantageous and disadvantageous.

some background info about this company CME: before they decided to venture out into manufacturing their own midi controllers, they were an OEM company that provided keys for yamaha and fatar keyboards. it is left to the individual companies to design their own hammer-touch and key action. on top of this, the sequencer transport buttons, sliders and knobs that u find on synths such as the motif are also provided by CME.

the m-audio weighs in at 21.3kg, and the CME at 23.5kg. just 2.1kg more than the m-audio.

to address your question, garagesale_01, the mobilepre will deliver the audio, but u'll still need USB midi interface. i have my doubts though, abt connecting so many USB devices together. latency won't be that great, for one. you'll be hard-pressed to achieve optimal DAW performance wtihout some serious OS tweaking. anyway, the fact that it's all running off a laptop too, feels a little fragile.

last i heard from sinamex, they are seriously back-ordered on their keystation stock. you'll probably have to wait quite a bit for your turn. CME is available in singapore, showroom at tong lee building. company is LSR Consultancy. i am currently one of their contact personnel. if you would like to know more about this product, please PM me. i shall not post commercial information here.
 
i have a UF6 and the drivers do not have any problems.

Its very stable for a usb unit.... the only problem is that the usb drivers do not work in the Protools LE environment.... so midi cable to the rescue.

Yes... i agree the UF8 is very heavy, but that makes it very sturdy too... and next week.... i'll have a new CME keyboard stand for my UF6. they have new stands for all the 4 series.

Also the UF SE series might be in too.... however, limited numbers will be provided to Singapore.

The piano hammer weighted feel of the UF8 is well balanced and the action is nice and smooth.... like all new keyboards.... you have to play it to season it... then it'll feel like an old piano should. When i had an old yamaha upright, it was tough to play.... but after some practise and breaking-in.... it starts to feel nicer... either that or my fingers strengthen.

So like all hammer-actioned midi controllers. You have to try it...

So i make no judgement here.

Cheers
 
Iansoh, great info. Looks like I'll definitely lean towards CME than M-audio, if I'm ever going to get a new midi controller. Great to hear that they have ironed out the driver problems.
 
at the moment no mLan drivers are available, and with the current drivers the firewire midi has a poorer midi support than the USB drivers, according to other users on the forum. sequencer transport buttons do not work when using firewire midi.

suggested routing is to use the onboard USB midi interface for midi signals and the firewire for audio. until the mLan drivers are released
 
Back
Top