Sorry, not true. I wouldn't say an Epi has less clarity, and todays Gibsons don't hold resale value at all. Unless you're talking about a historic, MAYBE they will.
u got anything to back up that statement?
afaik, the simple act of gibson continuously raising their retail prices every 1.5yrs is enough to have them maintain their value...nowadays even in as short a period of 5yrs.
generally, for gibson & fenders, it takes on avg 10yrs for its 2nd hand value to match what u originally bought it for then...and thts only for the regular production models.
take the SG classic for example, 2-3 yrs ago u could've bought one for USD799 brand new.
now u find them going on ebay for around USD750, as the retail of it has hit USD999.
buy an epi from 2-3yrs ago brand new and it would be pretty hard to sell it off for anything less than a 30% loss.
obviously the same doesnt really hold true for other makers, unless they're fender or one of the other big shots.
but back to the topic.
seems some ppl are confusing the 1959 with the tribute model.
the 1959 is limited to 1959 copies worldwide and comes with burstbuckers.
the tribute model isnt, and has gibson '57 classics.
there are of cos other small differences that make the 1959 more 'period correct' to what the actual gibson was, and that also accounts for the fact that its street price is roughly USD200-300 more than the tribute model, which means its also more expensive than the basic gibson lp studio.
so yea, imo if you're going for the 1959 model, by all means go ahead...tho knowing epiphone it will eventually end up as a production run model a couple yrs down the road...but of cos thats hard to say right now.
but if all you're going for is the tribute model, stick to the gibson lp studio.