Bands..

Actually , in your opinion , PLEASE DEFINE OVER AND UNDER . :)

This is so that I get a clearer view of where you're actually getting to .
 
It's easy to do underrated. It's difficult as hell to do overrated. How do you know a band is overrated unless you've gone through their entire discography and such?

A few underrated bands I like which I think don't get enough exposure, or maybe just in Singapore(the ones in the brackets are the ones from a same genre/time that seem to be huge though:

Alice in Chains(Nirvana gets all the grunge time)
The Clash(people prefer Ramones and Sex Pistols)
Black Sabbath(everyone likes Ozzy, no one cares too much about 70s Sabbath. People tend to prefer Dio Sabbath or some other band of the time like Led Zep or Deep Purple)
Judas Priest(Iron Maiden is HUGE here, but Priest, one of the greatest NWOBHM bands, don't have all too many fans in sg)
Danzig(here only because the song Blood and Tears has been playing in my head non-stop for days)
Metal Church and Testament.

Once again this is more of a Singapore context.
 
judas priest is not considered to be a part of the NWOBHM movement though they are a big influence on iron maiden.

and i prefer ozzy era black sabbath to dio era black sabbath. actually i can't stand dio's singing, i think he is an overrated singer.
 
yeah bro i meant the general public's view. I guess Priest were way earlier, but they always get lumped into NWOBHM somehow. My bad.
 
Anthrax is rightly where they are..not overrated or underrated.

Actually I can't think of any bands whose overrated or underated...
 
Anthrax were part of the Big 4 of Thrash, what underrated you talking bout?

And yeah bro, the clash rocks. "the only band that matters."
 
its all subjective. metal is underrated :P

Not here on Soft, it isn't! :p

But among the teenage / youth population, YES. Metal is under-rated. Why? Because of Metalcore and Screamo!!! :evil::evil::evil:

Haha no offense to anybody.

And yeah I don't think any of the big four of thrash are under-rated, except... was Exodus part of the big four? I can't remember, to be honest. Testament seems to get more attention than Exodus. Testament wasn't in the big four but got a lot of attention, almost as much as the big four... Under-rated thrash metal bands? I'd say Sodom, Destruction, Vio-lence and Nuclear Assault.
 
How bout we stop with the hate replies and start posting your views... It's just an opinion man... How can you try to justify and change somebody's opinion...

Brutha you are entitled to your opinions but it'd be interesting to know what those were based on...

because if there ain't none than it's baseless.


Something must have triggered your thought process to label them as such.
 
EugeneSmasher: metal is underrated in the general population cos we have pop playing on radio :P

i thought the big 4 are Metallica, Megadeth, Slayer and Anthrax? correct me if im wrong, not exactly a thrash fan hahaah
 
hahah this thread has become a congregation for black metal enthusiasts!

*brings out corspe paint* Wait, is that supposed to be overrated? Oh heck, I'm putting it on anyway :twisted:

I think I know who started this thread and Metallica being overrated: Dave Mustaine. Admit it Diamond Dave, you're still bitter about getting kicked out (trivia: Did you know that a photographer got the news that he was going to be kicked out by the band even before Mustaine knew about it?)

Jokes aside, its an argument that will go on and on forever. For instance, I love Satyricon but people might diss me saying that "They are being mainstream and following the likes of Dimmu and CoF" and I will still listen to Satyricon because my ears are the ones listening to the band and supporting them throughout the years, not some kid teaching me what black metal should be all about. Not even if its Burzum (no, I will not burn churches with you mister, find someone else). In the end, its the music that matters and even with polarising views from different people, all of us have the luxury to enjoy both their early works and the current albums :)
 
Overall Metal is underrated la nowadays every gig oso black metal this, death metal that, screamo la, metalcore la, can't we have some decent headbanging metal. Make me so kek-sim.

Anyway Megadeth has been > Metallica ever since Rust in Peace
 
so much talk about overrated-ness and underrated-ness. still ,in the end its just comes down to a simple discussion of "bands i like vs bands i dont like". There no objective measure of overratedness or underratedness anyway. I can say that lady gaga is extremely underrated, and theres no objective way which you can prove me wrong.

Which is why i feel the whole series of overrated/underrated threads are pointless, and 'OVERRATED'.

Seriously why not just change the topic to "bands i like vs bands i dont like". It'll be less controversial, less offending.
 
Last edited:
so much talk about overrated-ness and underrated-ness. still ,in the end its just comes down to a simple discussion of "bands i like vs bands i dont like". There no objective measure of overratedness or underratedness anyway. I can say that lady gaga is extremely underrated, and theres no objective way which you can prove me wrong.

Which is why i feel the whole series of overrated/underrated threads are pointless, and 'OVERRATED'.

Seriously why not just change the topic to "bands i like vs bands i dont like". It'll be less controversial, less offending.

lolwat. no over/under rated bands, but got overrated threads. hmm.
 
Back
Top