Is it easier to learn through lessons?

xEnOnn

New member
I have recently just started to learn guitar on my own. I am learning through books and internet videos. However, I found it difficult to progress much and sometimes I don't even know if I am playing the right way.

Worst still, I always got that "tong" and buzzing sound when I strike the strings. It is like the sound if my fingers are not pressing hard enough or my other fingers have accidentally touched on the other strings. My fingers also couldn't stretch far enough to reach the frets in certain chords. To make it simple, it just don't sound nice whenever I strike the strings.

So with these much difficulties, I am starting to think if it would be better to sign up for a guitar course and have someone teaching? How are your guitar lessons usually like? I am worry that the lessons will just print out the chords and make me follow and play on my own. If like that, I may as well see from books and play myself.
 
Well, there are two ways to learn. Self-learning and through guitar lessons.


Self-learning:

Well, you could teach yourself guitar if you have the determination.

For me, i planned to learn guitar from a friend. However, I could not understand what he teach over the time.

He just taught me how to place my fingers on the fretboard and teach me strumming pattern. I got fed-up a while later because he did not teach me anything about chords actually.

So, I got myself a chord book, learning different chords, learning how to read chord shapes. After this, I taught myself some simple songs and try to imitate the strumming pattern accurately according to how the song played.

As I progress further, some songs are played differently. Especially when you need to mute strings (when you learn to play power chords). Also, learning tabs to play required riffs or solos.

It took me about 2 years+ to play well. During this years, as I determine to be a "very good" player, I try to learn as much as possible about music and about the guitar instrument itself. Now, I've learned many techniques and about the guitar instrument (how to maintain well, change strings, basically technical stuff...)

However, learning is never ending. If you wish to go a step further to be a professional player, you've got to learn about music theory. (I've got to say, music theory aids people to play well and also to understand what's music is all about.)

(Actually it's ok if u dont wanna to learn music theory, as learning chords and tabs and some "guitaring" techniques really makes one be able to play basic guitar.)

To me, i tried to teach myself using materials from books and internet but it was very difficult because I don't have any musical background. I couldn't understand some musical terms.

So if you want to self-learn, there is sort of a "limit" actually. If u gonna learn with your friends, you might have to be careful because they might have some bad habits which u could be influenced by them.


Thru guitar lessons:

Well it's good if you could get an experienced teacher to teach you because you would learn proper music techniques from them. They will guide you step by step. Besides, u will get a chance to sit for music exams (eg. ABRSM) and you will get qualification (eg. Grade 1,2,3,4,5,6 etc) if you pass well.

There are 2 ways to take guitar lessons. They are via a music school or private lessons. Well, I would recommend music school because it is much cheaper than private lessons. However, make sure you know what are they gonna offer you in the course.

For private lessons, it is much more expensive but you will be taught 1-to-1. However, there are some things you have to be wary of.

Some teachers are might play well, but not teach well. Hence, affecting your learning curve. Others might be an amateur (without qualifications) and a "cheat" (eg. ask you for money in advance and they don't turn up. There is a recent case happened here.)

If you wanna take up private lessons, do check on their qualifications.


Overall, I would say if I were you, I would rather take music lessons because they will teach you proper techniques. Too bad, i ain't got any $$$:(.

If you gonna play for hobby, then you go self-learning.


(I don't know whether some points you would agree with me or not. This is just my opinion. If needed, just take it with a pinch of salt. Do look up at older threads too.)
 
Last edited:
Qualification don't mean anything...

I know of some teacher without qualifications but teach really well....
and teacher with but can't teach...

all i can say is that u have to try the teachers to know.....
 
Qualification don't mean anything...

I know of some teacher without qualifications but teach really well....
and teacher with but can't teach...

all i can say is that u have to try the teachers to know.....

Agreed. I know quite a few guitarists personally who are good. In fact, professional, plays guitar for a living. But the thing is they don't even have grade 1 certification.
 
easier with guitar lessons

hi,
like you i started off self taught and had faced the same difficulties that all beginners did.

but to that effect i want to say that i was very very lucky that right from the start from posture wise to picking i didnt pick up any bad habits. so when i took some formal lessons i did not have to change much.

while many people swear by self learning there is always the danger of picking up the bad habits that will not only hinder your playing but also pose a threat to your health sometimes eg back problems, tendonitis,

so its good to have someone experienced to point out the proper ways to you.


and to answer the question proper yes, it is definintely easier to learn through formal lessons as you learn it faster. what you can learn through a teacher will just be a fraction of the time it will take for you to learn by yourself.
just think about how you tried to press the fretboard and experimented around with how to press it, if you had someone to suggest how best to hold the neck you would have learnt that in one lesson rather than maybe a week of struggling with it.

learning guitar through a teacher indirectly makes you a better player and i say indirectly because you still need to put in the practice time and also because it just makes you learn faster.

if you have a budget for lessons why not spend a bit on the basics? then once you think you are good to go on your own then you can stop and do the self learning thing. i think thats a better investment then having to spend more money trying to correct a bad habit later on in your playing
 
or if u want free lessons, matt (likui) will be giving one when he's meeting us on 29th :D

ok jokes aside, what crying statue said is quite true. get a teacher to teach u the basics 1st if u are on a tight budget. suck as much as u can out of him/her in as short a time as possible. then go solo.

hmmm just curious, u tried justinguitar.com yet?? he's actually quite a good teacher. i learnt from him when i just started. so when i went over to formal lessons i didnt have any bad habits that needed correction :D

as for ur fretting, try fretting close to the fret wire (the metal strip on ur fretboard). best is just behind it. thats what i think is causing the buzz. as for fingers not having enough dexterity, u'll get it if u practice enough :)
 
How are the guitar lesssons usually be taught? Just play the same chord over and over again, which I could do the same thing at home?

I find that a lot of the music schools only teach classic guitar lessons. Is it the same if I am play an acoustic guitar and go to a classic guitar lesson?
 
when you feel the pinch while paying for a lesson, it would most definitely encourage you to do better to make your money well spent.
 
I teach acoustic and electric in a school. I teach chords, scales to beginers and practice techniques, very important thing, people always say practice , practice more but how to practice that's very important thing. How do u practice your chords, how do you practice changing chords fast those are really important. How to practice, think about that
 
i started of teaching myself for about 3 months. also similar to yr story. i feel that im nt progressing.

after that, i took lessens and i could play way faster and better.

bt i also teach myself at the same time.

for an example, if my teacher teach me the beginner chord, at home, i will learn the harder chord on youtube/internet.

so, the nxt lesson i have, i alrdy knw how to play that chord. and if i have any trouble abt the chord i learn off the internet, i can juz ask him for help.
 
i started of teaching myself for about 3 months. also similar to yr story. i feel that im nt progressing.

after that, i took lessens and i could play way faster and better.

bt i also teach myself at the same time.

for an example, if my teacher teach me the beginner chord, at home, i will learn the harder chord on youtube/internet.

so, the nxt lesson i have, i alrdy knw how to play that chord. and if i have any trouble abt the chord i learn off the internet, i can juz ask him for help.

this is call hard working
 
I started guitar less than 2 months ago. I'm a self-taught. I totally understand how you feel. Paying a couple of hundreds and not being able to play, that feeling sucks.

For me, I just try to push on, look up strumming helps and start on simple songs, slowly progress. Once you get the hang of 1 or 2 simple songs to play, you'll love that hobby already.

Logically speaking, I'm a complete newbie who started less than 2 months. I'm able to play a couple of songs now, even performing at christmas! Well, practice makes perfect, I'm sure anyone would say that. Get a couple of friends to correct your mistakes, and never be afraid to ask!
 
Back
Top