ok ok.. to share my 2cents worth again.
First of all, it doesn't matter what genres u play.
a) U have to like the look of the guitar.
b)U have to feel shiok playingwith the guitar. Imagine, if u feel that using an Explorer to play your metallica riff, and u have hard time keepin it on ur lap, worth it or not?
c) U have to understand that most CDs that u had heard undergo millions of dollars worht of production process. No point seeking via that way cos it will only 'sound like them' in your bed room and not during your live shows.
d)My belief is there isn't such thing as Metal Guitar or Punk Guitar or Blues guitar.. think Iron Maiden...they are using Fender! A beri 'un-metal' guitar!
korrect?
So what i suggest is try to create a sound that u think is unique and shiok. In my opinion, that's what matters most. It's after all about being Creative and Original rite?
In music, there is no right or wrong.
Good luck with ur experiment!